Xylophone vs. Vibraphone — What's the Difference?
Edited by Tayyaba Rehman — By Urooj Arif — Updated on March 24, 2024
The xylophone produces bright, sharp tones using wooden bars, while the vibraphone has metal bars and motor-driven resonators for a softer, sustained sound.
Difference Between Xylophone and Vibraphone
Table of Contents
ADVERTISEMENT
Key Differences
The xylophone is characterized by its wooden bars, which are struck with mallets to produce a bright, sharp sound. On the other hand, the vibraphone features metal bars and includes motor-driven resonators with rotating discs.
While both instruments are played with mallets and are part of the percussion family, the technique and performance practices can vary significantly. Xylophone players often use harder mallets to emphasize the instrument's percussive nature and bright tone. In contrast, vibraphone players may choose softer mallets to enhance the instrument's melodic capabilities and sustain.
The xylophone has a longer history, with roots tracing back to ancient Africa and Asia, and has been used in various forms in many cultures' music. Its design and the materials used have evolved, but the principle of struck wooden bars remains constant. The vibraphone, developed in the early 20th century, represents a more modern innovation, with its metal bars and electronic vibrato mechanism reflecting advancements in musical instrument technology.
The choice between a xylophone and a vibraphone often depends on the musical context and desired sound. Composers and musicians select the xylophone for its bright, penetrating quality that cuts through an ensemble's texture, whereas the vibraphone is chosen for its mellow tone and the unique vibrato effect, suitable for creating atmospheric and expressive musical passages.
Comparison Chart
Bars Material
Wooden
Metal
ADVERTISEMENT
Sound Quality
Bright, sharp, and percussive
Softer, sustained, with a vibrato effect
Resonators
Simple tubes under each bar
Tubes with motor-driven rotating discs
Use of Pedals
None
Sustain pedal to control note length
Typical Mallets Used
Harder mallets for a brighter sound
Softer mallets for a mellower tone
Musical Genres
Classical, folk, and contemporary music
Jazz, classical, and contemporary music
History
Ancient origins in Africa and Asia
Developed in the early 20th century
Vibrato Capability
None
Yes, thanks to motor-driven resonators
Sound Duration
Short, decay quickly due to the nature of wood
Longer, can be sustained with the pedal
Compare with Definitions
Xylophone
Requires precise timing and technique due to its sharp, immediate sound.
Xylophone players practice complex rhythms to master the instrument's unique sound dynamics.
Vibraphone
A musical instrument with metal bars and motor-driven resonators for creating a sustained, vibrato sound.
The jazz musician's vibraphone solo added a smooth, flowing texture to the piece.
Xylophone
Often used in orchestral and folk music for its percussive and rhythmic qualities.
The xylophone added a lively rhythm to the orchestra's performance.
Vibraphone
Includes a pedal to control the length of notes, similar to a piano's sustain pedal.
The vibraphonist used the pedal to sustain notes, creating a lingering, atmospheric effect.
Xylophone
A musical instrument with a series of wooden bars of different lengths, played by striking with mallets.
The musician played a fast-paced melody on the xylophone, showcasing its distinctive, bright sound.
Vibraphone
A 20th-century invention, reflecting advancements in musical instrument design and technology.
The vibraphone, developed in the 1920s, showcases the era's innovative approach to musical expression.
Xylophone
Has a history dating back to ancient cultures, where it was used in ceremonial and musical contexts.
Historians have traced the xylophone's origins to early African and Asian civilizations.
Vibraphone
Preferred in jazz and ensemble settings for its mellow tone and expressive capabilities.
The vibraphone is a staple in jazz ensembles, known for its warm, resonant sound.
Xylophone
Can have bars made from various materials, including hardwoods and synthetics, affecting the tone.
The concert xylophone featured rosewood bars, known for their rich, resonant sound.
Vibraphone
Played with softer mallets to enhance the instrument's melodic and harmonic qualities.
Choosing the right mallets is crucial for a vibraphonist to achieve the desired sound texture.
Xylophone
The xylophone (from the Greek words ξύλον—xylon, "wood" + φωνή—phōnē, "sound, voice", literally meaning "sound of wood") is a musical instrument in the percussion family that consists of wooden bars struck by mallets. Like the glockenspiel, the xylophone essentially consists of a set of tuned keys arranged in the fashion of the keyboard of a piano.
Vibraphone
The vibraphone is a musical instrument in the struck idiophone subfamily of the percussion family. It consists of tuned metal bars and is usually played by holding two or four soft mallets and striking the bars.
Xylophone
A percussion instrument consisting of a mounted row of wooden bars that are graduated in length to sound a chromatic scale, played with two small mallets.
Vibraphone
A percussion instrument similar to a marimba but having metal bars and rotating disks in the resonators to produce a vibrato. Also called vibraharp.
Xylophone
(musical instrument) Any musical instrument (percussion idiophone) made of wooden slats graduated so as to make the sounds of the scale when struck with a small drumstick-like mallet; the standard Western concert xylophone or one of its derivatives.
Vibraphone
A percussion instrument with a double row of tuned metal bars, each above the tubular resonator containing a motor-driven rotating vane, giving a vibrato effect.
Xylophone
To play a xylophone or to play something else as though it was a xylophone.
Vibraphone
A percussion instrument similar to a xylophone but having metal bars and rotating disks in the resonators that produce a vibrato sound
Xylophone
To move above a ridged surface so as to hit every ridge, in a manner similar to playing quickly and sequentially on a xylophone.
Xylophone
An instrument common among the Russians, Poles, and Tartars, consisting of a series of strips of wood or glass graduated in length to the musical scale, resting on belts of straw, and struck with two small hammers. Called in Germany strohfiedel, or straw fiddle.
Xylophone
An instrument to determine the vibrative properties of different kinds of wood.
Xylophone
A percussion instrument with wooden bars tuned to produce a chromatic scale and with resonators; played with small mallets
Common Curiosities
What is the main difference between a xylophone and a vibraphone?
The main difference lies in their construction and sound: xylophones have wooden bars for a bright, sharp sound, while vibraphones have metal bars with resonators for a softer, sustained tone.
Can the vibraphone produce vibrato?
Yes, the vibraphone can produce vibrato thanks to its motor-driven resonators with rotating discs under each bar.
What genres of music commonly feature the xylophone?
The xylophone is commonly featured in classical, folk, and contemporary music genres, valued for its rhythmic and percussive qualities.
Are vibraphones heavy?
Yes, vibraphones tend to be heavier than xylophones due to their metal bars and the mechanism for the motor-driven resonators.
Can you play fast music on a vibraphone?
Yes, fast music can be played on a vibraphone, but the technique and mallet choice may differ from the xylophone due to its sustained sound and vibrato capability.
Do xylophones and vibraphones use the same type of mallets?
No, xylophones typically use harder mallets to accentuate their bright, percussive sound, while vibraphones use softer mallets for a mellower tone.
Is the vibraphone used in classical music?
Yes, the vibraphone is used in classical music, as well as jazz and contemporary genres, for its unique sound and expressive capabilities.
Which instrument is older, the xylophone or the vibraphone?
The xylophone is older, with origins tracing back to ancient Africa and Asia, whereas the vibraphone was developed in the early 20th century.
How does the pedal on a vibraphone work?
The pedal on a vibraphone controls the opening of the resonator tubes, allowing for sustained notes and silencing the vibrato effect when released, similar to the sustain pedal on a piano.
How do musicians control the duration of notes on a vibraphone?
Musicians control the duration of notes on a vibraphone using a pedal, similar to a piano's sustain pedal, allowing for longer, sustained sounds.
How do you choose mallets for playing the vibraphone or xylophone?
Choosing mallets depends on the desired sound: harder mallets for a brighter, more articulate sound on the xylophone, and softer, wrapped mallets for a warmer, mellower tone on the vibraphone.
What materials are xylophone bars made from?
Xylophone bars are traditionally made from hardwoods like rosewood or synthetic materials, each offering different qualities of sound resonance and durability.
Can a beginner start learning music with a xylophone or vibraphone?
Yes, beginners can start learning music with either instrument, but the xylophone might be more accessible due to its straightforward mechanics and the clear, percussive sound that helps in learning rhythms.
Why is the vibraphone commonly used in jazz music?
The vibraphone is commonly used in jazz music for its smooth, mellow tone and the ability to produce vibrato, which adds expressiveness and depth to jazz compositions and improvisations.
Share Your Discovery
Previous Comparison
Jam vs. Marmalade
Next Comparison
Shawn vs. ShaunAuthor Spotlight
Written by
Urooj ArifUrooj is a skilled content writer at Ask Difference, known for her exceptional ability to simplify complex topics into engaging and informative content. With a passion for research and a flair for clear, concise writing, she consistently delivers articles that resonate with our diverse audience.
Edited by
Tayyaba RehmanTayyaba Rehman is a distinguished writer, currently serving as a primary contributor to askdifference.com. As a researcher in semantics and etymology, Tayyaba's passion for the complexity of languages and their distinctions has found a perfect home on the platform. Tayyaba delves into the intricacies of language, distinguishing between commonly confused words and phrases, thereby providing clarity for readers worldwide.
