Sodium Perborate vs. Sodium Percarbonate — What's the Difference?
Edited by Tayyaba Rehman — By Fiza Rafique — Published on December 6, 2023
Sodium perborate is an oxygen bleach compound used in detergents and cosmetics, while sodium percarbonate is a solid peroxide that releases hydrogen peroxide and is also used in cleaning agents.
Difference Between Sodium Perborate and Sodium Percarbonate
Table of Contents
ADVERTISEMENT
Key Differences
Sodium Perborate is a white, crystalline chemical compound that serves as an oxygen bleach in various cleaning products, particularly in detergents. On the other hand, Sodium Percarbonate is a chemical that, when dissolved in water, releases hydrogen peroxide, making it a popular ingredient in eco-friendly cleaning products and laundry detergents.
Both compounds are sources of active oxygen, which is why they are effective stain removers. Sodium Perborate, specifically, is often found in powdered detergents, acting as a stable source of active oxygen. Sodium Percarbonate, in contrast, is favored for its environmentally friendly nature, as it breaks down into water, oxygen, and soda ash.
While Sodium Perborate needs higher temperatures to activate its bleaching capability effectively, Sodium Percarbonate can work efficiently in cooler water. This makes the latter a more versatile cleaning agent, especially for cold-water washing.
Sodium Perborate exists in various hydrate forms, each with different water molecules attached to them. Sodium Percarbonate, however, is a simple combination of sodium carbonate and hydrogen peroxide, making its formulation straightforward.
Safety-wise, both chemicals should be handled with care. Sodium Perborate can release boron into the environment, which might be of ecological concern. Sodium Percarbonate, while generally safe and biodegradable, can still cause irritation upon direct contact or inhalation.
ADVERTISEMENT
Comparison Chart
Chemical Composition
Contains borate ion
Combination of sodium carbonate and hydrogen peroxide
Activation Temperature
Requires higher temperatures
Works effectively in cooler water
Environmental Impact
Can release boron
Biodegradable and eco-friendly
Form
Exists in various hydrate forms
Straightforward combination
Common Use
Oxygen bleach in detergents and cosmetics
Eco-friendly cleaning products and laundry detergents
Compare with Definitions
Sodium Perborate
A white, crystalline chemical used as an oxygen bleach.
Many laundry detergents contain sodium perborate as a primary bleaching agent.
Sodium Percarbonate
A chemical compound that releases hydrogen peroxide when dissolved.
Sodium percarbonate is a primary ingredient in many eco-friendly laundry detergents.
Sodium Perborate
A compound often used in cosmetics and pharmaceuticals.
The toothpaste's whitening effect was attributed to its sodium perborate content.
Sodium Percarbonate
Effective in removing stains, even in cold water.
With sodium percarbonate in the mix, cold-water washing became just as effective.
Sodium Perborate
Can have ecological concerns due to boron release.
Environmentalists raised concerns about the boron content in wastewater from sodium perborate.
Sodium Percarbonate
Can be an irritant upon direct exposure.
It's essential to wear gloves when handling pure sodium percarbonate to avoid skin irritation.
Sodium Perborate
An effective stain remover when activated at higher temperatures.
The stain was lifted after washing with warm water containing sodium perborate.
Sodium Percarbonate
An environmentally friendly alternative to traditional bleaches.
The brand highlighted its use of sodium percarbonate to appeal to eco-conscious consumers.
Sodium Perborate
Exists in various hydrate forms.
The manufacturer opted for monohydrate sodium perborate due to its higher stability.
Sodium Percarbonate
Decomposes into water, oxygen, and soda ash.
One of the advantages of sodium percarbonate is its benign decomposition products.
Common Curiosities
Do both compounds release active oxygen?
Yes, both sodium perborate and sodium percarbonate release active oxygen, making them effective stain removers.
Are there environmental concerns associated with sodium perborate?
Yes, sodium perborate can release boron, which might be of ecological concern.
Is sodium percarbonate environmentally friendly?
Sodium percarbonate is considered eco-friendly as it decomposes into water, oxygen, and soda ash.
What are the primary uses of sodium perborate and sodium percarbonate?
Sodium perborate is mainly used in detergents and cosmetics, while sodium percarbonate is used in eco-friendly cleaning products.
Which compound works effectively in cold water?
Sodium percarbonate can effectively work in cold water, while sodium perborate requires higher temperatures.
Is direct exposure to these compounds safe?
Direct exposure can cause irritation; it's advisable to handle them with care and use protective gear.
Which compound is commonly found in tooth whitening products?
Sodium perborate is often used in tooth whitening products.
Do both chemicals serve as bleaching agents?
Yes, both sodium perborate and sodium percarbonate act as bleaching agents in various products.
Can sodium percarbonate replace sodium perborate in all applications?
Not necessarily, as they have different properties and activation temperatures.
What happens when sodium percarbonate is dissolved in water?
It releases hydrogen peroxide, making it a popular cleaning agent.
Are there any safety precautions to consider while using these chemicals?
Yes, avoid inhalation, direct contact, and ensure good ventilation when using products containing these chemicals.
Are these compounds biodegradable?
Sodium percarbonate is biodegradable, but sodium perborate can have ecological concerns due to boron release.
Which compound is more common in eco-friendly products?
Sodium percarbonate is more commonly used in eco-friendly products due to its environmental benefits.
How are these compounds different in their chemical structure?
Sodium perborate contains a borate ion, while sodium percarbonate is a combination of sodium carbonate and hydrogen peroxide.
Do they have any other industrial applications apart from cleaning?
While primarily used in cleaning, sodium perborate finds use in cosmetics and pharmaceuticals, and sodium percarbonate can be used in aquaculture to supply oxygen.
Share Your Discovery
Previous Comparison
Lipids vs. Fats
Next Comparison
CD-R vs. CD-ROMAuthor Spotlight
Written by
Fiza RafiqueFiza Rafique is a skilled content writer at AskDifference.com, where she meticulously refines and enhances written pieces. Drawing from her vast editorial expertise, Fiza ensures clarity, accuracy, and precision in every article. Passionate about language, she continually seeks to elevate the quality of content for readers worldwide.
Edited by
Tayyaba RehmanTayyaba Rehman is a distinguished writer, currently serving as a primary contributor to askdifference.com. As a researcher in semantics and etymology, Tayyaba's passion for the complexity of languages and their distinctions has found a perfect home on the platform. Tayyaba delves into the intricacies of language, distinguishing between commonly confused words and phrases, thereby providing clarity for readers worldwide.
