Excellent vs. Proficient — What's the Difference?
By Tayyaba Rehman — Updated on November 6, 2023
Excellent denotes outstanding or superior quality, while proficient means competent or skilled to a good standard.
Difference Between Excellent and Proficient
Table of Contents
ADVERTISEMENT
Key Differences
Excellent is a term that conveys the highest quality or outstanding performance in a certain field or activity. It is a level of praise that suggests going above and beyond proficiency. For example, in academics, an excellent grade would be at the top of the grading scale.
Proficient, on the other hand, implies competence or a good standard of skill, but not necessarily the highest level. It is often used to describe a level of skill that meets the requirements of a task well but doesn't surpass them with distinction as 'excellent' does.
An excellent performance is usually marked by a flair or distinction that sets it apart from the norm. It’s often used when comparing the best in a group, highlighting a degree of excellence that surpasses mere proficiency.
Proficiency suggests a level of skill and experience that indicates that the individual is adept and knowledgeable. However, it does not carry the connotation of the exceptionalism implied by excellence. A proficient worker can handle all typical tasks confidently but may not excel in innovation or creativity.
In essence, excellence is about reaching the peak with standout attributes, while proficiency is about having the necessary skills to perform a job competently. While all excellent performers are proficient, not all proficient individuals may be considered excellent.
ADVERTISEMENT
Comparison Chart
Connotation
Superior quality, outstanding performance.
Competent or skilled enough to meet standards.
Expectation
Above and beyond what is required.
Meets the necessary standard.
Usage
Often used for top performers or products.
Used for individuals who are skilled and competent.
Frequency
Less common, denotes a high standard.
More common, denotes a satisfactory standard.
Implication
May imply a degree of uniqueness.
Does not imply uniqueness, just capability.
Compare with Definitions
Excellent
Outstanding or superior
His excellent command of the language is impressive.
Proficient
Well advanced in an art, occupation, or branch of knowledge
He's proficient in his knowledge of history.
Excellent
Of the highest or finest quality
Her excellent performance earned a standing ovation.
Proficient
Displaying competence; well-practiced
As a proficient editor, she quickly corrected the errors.
Excellent
Extremely good or proficient
She has an excellent understanding of the subject.
Proficient
Having or showing knowledge and skill
The technician was very proficient at solving the problem.
Excellent
Marked by distinction
He received an excellent review for his latest work.
Proficient
Adequate or acceptable in standard
Her piano playing is proficient for a beginner.
Excellent
Extremely good; outstanding
Their results are excellent
The lorry was in excellent condition
Proficient
Competent or skilled in doing something
She is proficient in several programming languages.
Excellent
Used to indicate approval or pleasure
‘What a lovely idea! Excellent!’
Proficient
Competent or skilled in doing or using something
I was proficient at my job
She felt reasonably proficient in Italian
Excellent
Of the highest or finest quality; exceptionally good for its kind
Enjoyed an excellent meal at the restaurant.
Proficient
A person who is proficient
He became a proficient in Latin and Greek
Excellent
(Archaic) Being so to an extreme degree.
Proficient
Having or marked by an advanced degree of competence, as in an art, vocation, profession, or branch of learning.
Excellent
Having excelled, having surpassed.
Proficient
A person who exhibits such competence; an expert.
Excellent
Of higher or the highest quality; splendid.
Proficient
Good at something; skilled; fluent; practiced, especially in relation to a task or skill.
He was a proficient writer with an interest in human nature.
Excellent
Exceptionally good of its kind.
Proficient
An expert.
Excellent
Superior in kind or degree, irrespective of moral quality.
Proficient
One who has made considerable advances in any business, art, science, or branch of learning; an expert; an adept; as, proficient in a trade; a proficient in mathematics, music, etc.
Excellent
(obsolete) Excellently.
Proficient
Well advanced in any branch of knowledge or skill; possessed of considerable acquirements; well-skilled; versed; adept,
Excellent
Excelling; surpassing others in some good quality or the sum of qualities; of great worth; eminent, in a good sense; superior; as, an excellent man, artist, citizen, husband, discourse, book, song, etc.; excellent breeding, principles, aims, action.
To love . . . What I see excellent in good or fair.
Proficient
Having or showing knowledge and skill and aptitude;
Adept in handicrafts
An adept juggler
An expert job
A good mechanic
A practiced marksman
A proficient engineer
A lesser-known but no less skillful composer
The effect was achieved by skillful retouching
Excellent
Superior in kind or degree, irrespective of moral quality; - used with words of a bad significance.
Their sorrows are most excellent.
Excellent
Excellently; eminently; exceedingly.
Excellent
Of the highest quality;
Made an excellent speech
The school has excellent teachers
A first-class mind
Excellent
Exceptionally good
The chef prepared an excellent meal.
Common Curiosities
Can someone be proficient but not excellent?
Yes, proficiency indicates competence while excellence indicates a superior level.
Is "proficient" enough for a professional setting?
Yes, being proficient is often the required standard in professional settings.
Can a product be both excellent and proficient?
A product can be proficient in function but excellent in quality.
Is "excellent" better than "proficient"?
Yes, "excellent" implies a higher standard than "proficient."
Can "proficient" be used to grade academic work?
It's not common in grading but could be used to describe a student's competence.
Can one become proficient through training?
Yes, training can elevate one's skills to a proficient level.
Can "excellent" be subjective in performance reviews?
Yes, what one reviewer sees as excellent, another may not.
Are the terms "excellent" and "proficient" subjective?
Both can be subjective, but "excellent" is more likely to vary by opinion.
Does "excellent" imply rarity?
"Excellent" often suggests a level of quality or skill that is less common.
Does "excellent" require innate talent?
Not necessarily; it can also be achieved through hard work and dedication.
Does "proficient" suggest a learning curve?
Yes, it implies that a level of learning and skill has been achieved.
Are "excellent" skills always innate?
No, they can be developed over time with practice and effort.
Is it common to reach proficiency before excellence?
Typically, yes; proficiency is a step towards achieving excellence.
Is "excellent" used for grading?
Yes, it's often used to denote the highest achievable grade.
In job postings, what does "proficient" mean?
It means the employer is looking for someone competent in certain skills.
Share Your Discovery
Previous Comparison
Malbec vs. Tempranillo
Next Comparison
Closet vs. PantryAuthor Spotlight
Written by
Tayyaba RehmanTayyaba Rehman is a distinguished writer, currently serving as a primary contributor to askdifference.com. As a researcher in semantics and etymology, Tayyaba's passion for the complexity of languages and their distinctions has found a perfect home on the platform. Tayyaba delves into the intricacies of language, distinguishing between commonly confused words and phrases, thereby providing clarity for readers worldwide.
