Ask Difference

Dehydration by H2SO4 vs. Dehydration H3PO4 — What's the Difference?

By Tayyaba Rehman & Maham Liaqat — Published on February 21, 2024
Dehydration by H2SO4 involves a strong, highly exothermic reaction, often leading to carbonization, while H3PO4 offers milder conditions, reducing the risk of side reactions and carbonization, making it suitable for more sensitive substrates.
Dehydration by H2SO4 vs. Dehydration H3PO4 — What's the Difference?

Difference Between Dehydration by H2SO4 and Dehydration H3PO4


Key Differences

Dehydration reactions involve the removal of water from organic compounds, often to form alkenes from alcohols. Both sulfuric acid (H2SO4) and phosphoric acid (H3PO4) can catalyze these reactions, but their chemical properties and reactivity differ significantly, influencing the outcome and applicability of the dehydration process.
H2SO4 is a strong acid and a powerful dehydrating agent, capable of removing water from a wide range of organic molecules. Its use in dehydration reactions is characterized by high efficiency and speed due to its strong acid nature. However, the reactions with H2SO4 can be highly exothermic and sometimes uncontrollable, leading to potential carbonization of the organic substrate. This makes H2SO4 suitable for robust molecules that can withstand harsh conditions, but it may not be ideal for more sensitive or complex molecules where selectivity and product integrity are crucial.
On the other hand, H3PO4 is a relatively weaker acid compared to H2SO4, offering milder reaction conditions for dehydration processes. The use of H3PO4 reduces the risk of overreaction and side reactions, including carbonization, making it more suitable for delicate substrates that require gentler handling. The milder conditions provided by H3PO4 can be particularly advantageous in dehydration reactions where the preservation of functional groups or stereochemistry is important.
The choice between H2SO4 and H3PO4 for a dehydration reaction depends on the substrate's sensitivity, the desired product, and the need to control side reactions. While H2SO4 might be the choice for simple, robust molecules where speed and efficiency are desired, H3PO4 is often preferred for substrates that could degrade under harsh conditions or when a more selective outcome is needed.
In practical applications, such as in the production of biofuels or in fine chemical synthesis, the decision to use H2SO4 or H3PO4 will also consider factors like reaction scalability, environmental impact, and the ease of removing the acid catalyst from the product.

Comparison Chart

Acid Strength

Strong acid
Weaker acid


High, can lead to carbonization
Milder, less likely to cause carbonization


Robust molecules resistant to harsh conditions
Sensitive substrates requiring gentle conditions

Side Reactions

More likely, due to high reactivity
Less likely, offers more control


Efficient for simple dehydration reactions
Preferred for complex molecules or where selectivity is needed

Compare with Definitions

Dehydration by H2SO4

Highly exothermic reactions requiring careful control.
Adequate cooling is necessary to manage the exothermic nature of H2SO4 dehydration.

Dehydration H3PO4

Preferred for substrates sensitive to harsh conditions.
Dehydration of geraniol to geranial uses H3PO4 to avoid overreaction.

Dehydration by H2SO4

Can lead to carbonization at high temperatures.
Overheating during dehydration can cause substrate degradation.

Dehydration H3PO4

Used in fine chemical and pharmaceutical synthesis.
H3PO4 catalyzes the dehydration in the synthesis of certain heterocycles.

Dehydration by H2SO4

Widely used in large-scale chemical production.
H2SO4 catalyzes dehydration in the manufacture of diethyl ether.

Dehydration H3PO4

Less risk of carbonization, suitable for complex molecules.
Gentle dehydration of citronellol to isopulegol employs H3PO4.

Dehydration by H2SO4

A powerful dehydration method, suitable for stable compounds.
H2SO4 is used to dehydrate ethanol to ethene in industrial settings.

Dehydration H3PO4

Milder dehydration conditions, preserving functional groups.
H3PO4 is used in the dehydration of glucose to 5-hydroxymethylfurfural in biomass conversion.

Dehydration by H2SO4

Risk of side reactions, especially with sensitive molecules.
Dehydration of sugars with H2SO4 can result in charring.

Dehydration H3PO4

Offers selectivity in dehydration reactions.
H3PO4 selectively dehydrates serine to dehydroalanine in peptides.

Common Curiosities

Can H2SO4 cause carbonization in dehydration reactions?

Yes, due to its high reactivity and exothermic nature, H2SO4 can cause carbonization, especially at elevated temperatures.

Is H3PO4 as effective as H2SO4 in dehydration?

H3PO4 is effective but generally offers milder conditions; it may not be as fast or efficient as H2SO4 but is preferable for substrates that require gentler treatment.

What is the main advantage of using H2SO4 for dehydration?

H2SO4's main advantage is its strong dehydrating power, making it highly efficient for simple dehydration reactions.

Can dehydration by H3PO4 be used in fine chemical synthesis?

Yes, H3PO4 is often used in fine chemical and pharmaceutical synthesis where selectivity and the preservation of sensitive functional groups are important.

What are the environmental considerations when choosing between H2SO4 and H3PO4 for dehydration?

The choice may consider factors like the toxicity, handling, and disposal of the acids, with a preference for conditions that minimize environmental impact.

How do the risks of side reactions compare between H2SO4 and H3PO4 in dehydration processes?

The risk of side reactions is higher with H2SO4 due to its strong acid nature, while H3PO4 provides more control over the reaction, minimizing side reactions.

How does the choice of acid affect the yield and purity of the desired product in dehydration reactions?

The choice of acid can significantly affect both yield and purity; stronger acids like H2SO4 may offer high yields but with a risk of impurities from side reactions, whereas H3PO4 may provide a cleaner product due to milder conditions.

Why might one choose H3PO4 over H2SO4 for a dehydration reaction?

H3PO4 is chosen for its milder conditions, reducing the risk of side reactions and carbonization, suitable for sensitive or complex molecules.

What type of substrates are suitable for dehydration with H2SO4?

Robust molecules that can withstand harsh conditions without degrading are suitable for dehydration with H2SO4.

Are there any specific safety measures required when using H2SO4 for dehydration?

Yes, due to its highly exothermic reactions and potential for corrosive splashes, appropriate safety measures including protective gear and adequate cooling are essential when using H2SO4.

Share Your Discovery

Share via Social Media
Embed This Content
Embed Code
Share Directly via Messenger

Author Spotlight

Written by
Tayyaba Rehman
Tayyaba Rehman is a distinguished writer, currently serving as a primary contributor to As a researcher in semantics and etymology, Tayyaba's passion for the complexity of languages and their distinctions has found a perfect home on the platform. Tayyaba delves into the intricacies of language, distinguishing between commonly confused words and phrases, thereby providing clarity for readers worldwide.
Co-written by
Maham Liaqat

Popular Comparisons

Trending Comparisons

New Comparisons

Trending Terms