Acedia vs. Ennui — What's the Difference?
Edited by Tayyaba Rehman — By Maham Liaqat — Updated on April 16, 2024
Acedia involves spiritual or mental sloth, linked to medieval religious contexts, while ennui signifies a feeling of weariness and dissatisfaction from boredom, commonly used in modern contexts.
Difference Between Acedia and Ennui
Table of Contents
ADVERTISEMENT
Key Differences
Acedia is a term rooted in early Christian monasticism, describing a state of listlessness or torpor, often seen as a spiritual crisis. In contrast, ennui, a French term adopted into English, describes a general sense of boredom and dissatisfaction with life that isn't necessarily spiritual.
Acedia was traditionally considered a deadly sin in Christian theology, signifying a profound spiritual lethargy and lack of caring. Whereas ennui does not carry a moral or spiritual judgment but is more about a pervasive sense of disinterest and tedium with life's activities.
Historically, acedia was specifically linked to the monk's struggle to maintain a devout life, reflecting an existential crisis in a religious context. On the other hand, ennui is often associated with the existentialist philosophy, emphasizing the absurdity and monotony of human life in a secular context.
In literary contexts, acedia is depicted as a deep-seated condition affecting one's spiritual duties and purpose. Ennui, however, is frequently portrayed in literature as a broader societal issue, affecting individuals who find no meaning or joy in their daily experiences.
The remedies for acedia in historical texts often involve spiritual discipline and community life, aiming to reignite the spiritual fervor of the individual. In contrast, ennui is typically addressed through finding new interests or passions to invigorate one's outlook on life.
ADVERTISEMENT
Comparison Chart
Definition
Spiritual or mental sloth, particularly in a religious context.
Boredom and dissatisfaction from lack of interest.
Origin
Early Christian monasticism.
French existentialist thought.
Context
Mainly religious and spiritual.
Secular and philosophical.
Literary Themes
Spiritual crisis and struggle.
Societal malaise and personal disinterest.
Typical Remedies
Spiritual disciplines, community involvement.
Seeking new passions, changing routines.
Compare with Definitions
Acedia
Aversion to activity.
Acedia often leaves individuals feeling listless and uninspired.
Ennui
Discontent from monotony.
Ennui can make even exciting activities feel mundane.
Acedia
Disengagement from routine duties.
His acedia made even daily chores seem daunting.
Ennui
A sense of jaded indifference.
Years in the same job led to a deep sense of ennui.
Acedia
Emotional or mental inactivity.
Acedia kept him from fulfilling his daily tasks.
Ennui
Feeling of boredom due to lack of interest.
Ennui often strikes during long, uneventful summer days.
Acedia
Lack of enthusiasm for life.
Acedia can often be mistaken for depression.
Ennui
Weariness and dissatisfaction with life.
The artist's ennui drove him to seek new experiences abroad.
Acedia
Spiritual neglect or indifference.
The monk combated acedia by increasing his hours of prayer.
Ennui
Existential boredom.
Philosophers often discuss ennui in terms of life's inherent meaninglessness.
Acedia
Acedia (; also accidie or accedie , from Latin acēdia, and this from Greek ἀκηδία, "negligence", ἀ- "lack of" -κηδία "care") has been variously defined as a state of listlessness or torpor, of not caring or not being concerned with one's position or condition in the world. In ancient Greece akidía literally meant an inert state without pain or care.
Ennui
Listlessness and dissatisfaction resulting from lack of interest; boredom
"The servants relieved their ennui with gambling and gossip about their masters" (John Barth).
Acedia
Spiritual torpor and apathy; ennui.
Ennui
A gripping listlessness or melancholia caused by boredom; depression.
Acedia
Spiritual or mental sloth.
Ennui
(transitive) To make bored or listless; to weary.
Acedia
Apathy; a lack of care or interest; indifference.
Ennui
A feeling of weariness and disgust; dullness and languor of spirits, arising from satiety or want of interest; tedium.
Acedia
Boredom. en
Ennui
The feeling of being bored by something tedious
Acedia
Apathy and inactivity in the practice of virtue (personified as one of the deadly sins).
Acedia
Apathy and inactivity in the practice of virtue (personified as one of the deadly sins)
Common Curiosities
Is ennui always negative?
Ennui is typically seen as negative, though it can sometimes lead to positive changes if it motivates one to seek new interests.
What is acedia primarily associated with?
Acedia is primarily associated with spiritual or mental sloth, especially in religious contexts.
Can acedia affect anyone outside of religious settings?
While traditionally a religious term, acedia can be applied metaphorically to describe any form of spiritual or emotional lethargy.
How did ennui enter English usage?
Ennui was adopted into English from French, particularly through literary and philosophical texts in the 18th and 19th centuries.
How does ennui differ from acedia in context?
Ennui is more secular and related to a general feeling of dissatisfaction and boredom, not linked to spiritual aspects.
What might alleviate ennui?
Engaging in new hobbies, traveling, or changing one’s routine are common recommendations for overcoming ennui.
What kind of remedy is typically suggested for acedia?
Remedies for acedia often involve increased engagement in spiritual or communal activities.
What is the impact of acedia on personal life?
Acedia can severely impact personal motivation and fulfillment, leading to neglect of personal and professional responsibilities.
Does acedia have a modern equivalent in psychological terms?
Acedia can be closely related to what is now recognized as depression in modern psychology.
Are there historical figures known for discussing acedia?
Early Christian monks and theologians like Evagrius Ponticus and Thomas Aquinas discussed acedia extensively.
Why is ennui a common theme in existential literature?
Ennui is used to explore themes of absurdity, existential crisis, and the search for meaning.
How does society view acedia today?
Acedia is less commonly recognized today but is still relevant in discussions of spiritual health and well-being.
Is ennui considered a serious condition?
While not a clinical condition, ennui can seriously affect one's quality of life and mental health.
How is ennui depicted in modern media?
Ennui is often depicted in films and novels as a catalyst for character development or plot progression.
Can acedia and ennui coexist in a person?
Yes, a person can experience both acedia and ennui, feeling both spiritual emptiness and worldly boredom.
Share Your Discovery
Previous Comparison
Annoyance vs. Nuisance
Next Comparison
Divide vs. ShareAuthor Spotlight
Written by
Maham Liaqat
Edited by
Tayyaba RehmanTayyaba Rehman is a distinguished writer, currently serving as a primary contributor to askdifference.com. As a researcher in semantics and etymology, Tayyaba's passion for the complexity of languages and their distinctions has found a perfect home on the platform. Tayyaba delves into the intricacies of language, distinguishing between commonly confused words and phrases, thereby providing clarity for readers worldwide.
