Transdermal vs. Intradermal — What's the Difference?
By Urooj Arif & Fiza Rafique — Updated on March 20, 2024
Transdermal involves medication delivery through the skin to the bloodstream, while intradermal refers to injections within the skin layers.
Difference Between Transdermal and Intradermal
Table of Contents
ADVERTISEMENT
Key Differences
Transdermal delivery systems, like patches, allow medication to be absorbed through the skin directly into the bloodstream, offering a steady dose over time. Intradermal, on the other hand, involves injecting a substance just beneath the skin's surface, primarily used for diagnostic purposes like allergy tests.
Transdermal methods are designed for systemic effects, impacting the entire body by releasing medication into the bloodstream over extended periods. Intradermal injections aim for localized effects, often utilized for sensitivity and immune response testing, with minimal systemic absorption.
Transdermal patches provide a non-invasive alternative to oral or injectable medications, reducing gastrointestinal side effects and bypassing liver metabolism. Intradermal injections require precise technique, injecting into the dermis layer to assess reactions to substances like tuberculin.
The effectiveness of transdermal delivery can be influenced by the skin's condition and the molecular size of the medication, requiring enhancers to aid absorption. Intradermal delivery is more about the immediate local reaction, used for vaccines like the Bacillus Calmette-Guérin (BCG) or diagnostic tests.
Transdermal applications are often used for chronic conditions requiring continuous medication, such as pain management or hormone therapy. Intradermal routes are less about ongoing treatment and more focused on testing or localized treatment, such as local anesthesia or certain vaccines.
ADVERTISEMENT
Comparison Chart
Method
Medication absorbed through the skin to bloodstream
Injection within the skin layers
Purpose
Systemic effects, long-term medication delivery
Localized effects, diagnostic testing
Application
Patches, gels
Injections (e.g., allergy tests, BCG vaccine)
Effects
Impacts the entire body
Primarily affects the local area of injection
Technique
Non-invasive, adheres to skin
Requires precise injection into the dermis
Compare with Definitions
Transdermal
Medication penetrates the skin for systemic effects.
Nicotine patches help smokers quit by delivering nicotine transdermally.
Intradermal
Used for targeted areas, often for diagnostic purposes.
Tuberculin skin tests involve intradermal injections to test for TB exposure.
Transdermal
Provides steady medication over time.
Hormone replacement therapies often use transdermal patches for consistent dosing.
Intradermal
Common in allergy tests and immune response assessments.
Intradermal injections are used in Mantoux tests to assess TB immunity.
Transdermal
Reduces first-pass metabolism effects.
Transdermal delivery can avoid gastrointestinal side effects associated with oral medications.
Intradermal
Some vaccines are administered intradermally for effective immunization.
The BCG vaccine for tuberculosis may be given intradermally in some countries.
Transdermal
May require enhancers for effective delivery.
Certain transdermal gels include permeation enhancers to aid absorption.
Intradermal
Designed for localized reaction with little absorption into the bloodstream.
Allergy testing relies on intradermal injections to observe local skin reactions.
Transdermal
Offers an alternative to oral or injectable routes.
Transdermal pain relief patches offer an option for those who avoid needles.
Intradermal
Injection into the dermis layer.
Intradermal flu vaccines require skilled healthcare professionals for proper administration.
Transdermal
Transdermal is a route of administration wherein active ingredients are delivered across the skin for systemic distribution. Examples include transdermal patches used for medicine delivery.
Intradermal
Within or between the layers of the skin
An intradermal injection.
Transdermal
Relating to or denoting the application of a medicine or drug through the skin, typically by using an adhesive patch, so that it is absorbed slowly into the body.
Intradermal
Relating to areas between the layers of the skin.
Transdermal
Through or by way of the skin
Transdermal inoculation.
Intradermal
Within the skin.
Transdermal
Through the unbroken skin (as for example with measurements of blood glucose level with an optical glucometer using photometry or of oxygen saturation via pulse oximetry).
Intradermal
Relating to areas between the layers of the skin;
An intradermal injection
Transdermal
A transdermal patch or implant.
Transdermal
Through the unbroken skin; refers to medications applied directly to the skin (creams or ointments) or in time-release forms (skin patches);
Transdermal estrogen
Percutaneous absorption
Common Curiosities
What is an intradermal injection used for?
Intradermal injections are primarily used for diagnostic testing, like allergy tests, or for vaccines that require localized absorption.
How does intradermal delivery differ from subcutaneous or intramuscular?
Intradermal delivery places the medication just below the skin's surface, whereas subcutaneous and intramuscular injections deposit medication deeper, into the fat layer or muscle, respectively.
What factors affect the absorption of transdermal medications?
Factors include the skin's condition, the medication's molecular size and solubility, and the presence of absorption enhancers in the formulation.
Can transdermal patches cause skin irritation?
Yes, some individuals may experience skin irritation or allergic reactions at the site of a transdermal patch.
Are there environmental considerations for disposing of transdermal patches?
Yes, used patches may still contain active medication and should be disposed of properly to prevent accidental exposure or environmental contamination.
What is transdermal medication delivery?
Transdermal delivery involves administering medication through the skin for systemic absorption, often using patches or gels.
Are transdermal systems suitable for acute conditions?
Transdermal systems are generally used for chronic conditions requiring steady medication delivery and not typically for acute conditions requiring rapid onset.
Can transdermal patches deliver all types of medication?
Not all medications are suitable for transdermal delivery; factors like molecule size and skin permeability limit the types of drugs that can be effectively delivered this way.
How do healthcare professionals choose between transdermal and intradermal administration?
The choice depends on the medication's purpose, desired effects, and the patient's condition. Transdermal is chosen for continuous systemic treatment, while intradermal is for localized or diagnostic purposes.
What are the advantages of intradermal injections?
Intradermal injections are useful for precise diagnostic testing and certain vaccinations, offering direct delivery to the skin's immune cells.
How long do transdermal patches work?
Transdermal patches can work for varying durations, from 24 hours to several days, depending on the medication and the design of the patch.
Is intradermal injection painful?
Intradermal injections can cause discomfort or pain due to the needle entering the skin, but the level of pain is generally minimal and short-lived.
Can intradermal injections cause systemic side effects?
While designed for localized effects, intradermal injections can occasionally cause systemic side effects if the substance has unintended absorption into the bloodstream.
How are transdermal patches applied?
Transdermal patches are applied to clean, dry skin, often on a flat area without much hair, and must adhere well to the skin to ensure proper medication delivery.
What is the "wheal" in intradermal injections?
The "wheal" is a small, raised area that forms at the injection site immediately after an intradermal injection, indicating proper delivery.
Share Your Discovery
Previous Comparison
Bastardy vs. Bastardry
Next Comparison
Float vs. SwimAuthor Spotlight
Written by
Urooj ArifUrooj is a skilled content writer at Ask Difference, known for her exceptional ability to simplify complex topics into engaging and informative content. With a passion for research and a flair for clear, concise writing, she consistently delivers articles that resonate with our diverse audience.
Co-written by
Fiza RafiqueFiza Rafique is a skilled content writer at AskDifference.com, where she meticulously refines and enhances written pieces. Drawing from her vast editorial expertise, Fiza ensures clarity, accuracy, and precision in every article. Passionate about language, she continually seeks to elevate the quality of content for readers worldwide.
