Burbot vs. Dogfish — What's the Difference?
Edited by Tayyaba Rehman — By Maham Liaqat — Updated on April 25, 2024
Burbot is a freshwater cod-like fish known for its mild taste and firm texture, while dogfish, a type of shark, offers a stronger flavor and tougher meat.
Difference Between Burbot and Dogfish
Table of Contents
ADVERTISEMENT
Key Differences
Burbot, primarily found in cold freshwater environments, is a species from the cod family, known for its elongated, lobed body and single barbel on the chin. Whereas dogfish are small to medium-sized sharks, found in both freshwater and marine environments, recognized for their spiny dorsal fins and lack of barbels.
Burbot thrives in deep, cold lakes and rivers in North America and Eurasia, making it a common target for ice fishing. On the other hand, dogfish often inhabit shallow waters and are frequently caught by coastal fishermen, with species like the spiny dogfish being found extensively across the Atlantic and Pacific oceans.
Burbot is celebrated in culinary circles for its delicate, white flesh which is often compared to lobster in taste when cooked. While dogfish meat, particularly from species like the spiny dogfish, is firmer and has a more pronounced flavor, making it less popular in mainstream cuisine but valued in certain regional dishes.
Burbot spawns in winter, under the ice, which is unique among freshwater fish. Whereas dogfish reproduce via eggs that develop and hatch inside the female before live young are born, showcasing a different reproductive strategy known as ovoviviparity.
Burbot is often pursued for sport fishing and its beneficial oils, rich in omega-3 fatty acids. Conversely, dogfish are frequently targeted in commercial fishing, mainly for their fins and meat, but are often considered bycatch in many fisheries.
ADVERTISEMENT
Comparison Chart
Habitat
Freshwater (lakes and rivers)
Mostly marine, some freshwater
Body Features
Elongated body, single barbel
Spiny dorsal fins, no barbels
Culinary Use
Mild, lobster-like taste
Stronger, tougher meat
Reproduction
Spawns under ice in winter
Ovoviviparous, live-bearing
Fishing Interest
Sport fishing, beneficial oils
Commercial, fins and meat
Compare with Definitions
Burbot
A freshwater fish belonging to the cod family.
The burbot is often caught during ice fishing expeditions.
Dogfish
Less favored in mainstream culinary uses.
Dogfish meat is tougher and more flavorful, often used in stews.
Burbot
Has a mild, delicate flavor.
The burbot's flesh is so tender and tasty, similar to lobster.
Dogfish
Reproduces by bearing live young.
Unlike many sharks, dogfish give birth to live pups.
Burbot
Known for its single chin barbel.
You can identify a burbot by the distinctive barbel on its chin.
Dogfish
A small to medium-sized shark species.
Dogfish are commonly found along the Atlantic coast.
Burbot
Spawns in the cold of winter under ice.
Burbot are unique as they spawn in extremely cold conditions under ice.
Dogfish
Known for its spiny dorsal fins.
The dogfish uses its spiny dorsal fins for protection against predators.
Burbot
Prized for its high omega-3 content.
Many choose burbot for its health benefits, particularly its omega-3 fatty acids.
Dogfish
Often caught as bycatch in commercial fishing.
Dogfish often end up as bycatch in nets intended for other fish.
Burbot
The burbot (Lota lota) is the only gadiform (cod-like) freshwater fish. It is also known as bubbot, mariah, freshwater cod, freshwater ling, freshwater cusk, the lawyer, coney-fish, lingcod, and eelpout.
Dogfish
A small sand-coloured bottom-dwelling shark with a long tail, common on European coasts.
Burbot
A freshwater food fish (Lota lota) of northern regions of the Northern Hemisphere, closely related to and resembling the cod and having a long barbel on the chin. Also called cusk, eelpout.
Dogfish
A small shark that resembles or is related to the dogfish, sometimes caught for food.
Burbot
A freshwater fish, taxonomic name Lota lota, which is similar to the ling and the cusk and spawns in the winter.
Dogfish
Any of various small sharks chiefly of the family Squalidae, often occurring in large schools.
Burbot
A fresh-water fish of the genus Lota, having on the nose two very small barbels, and a larger one on the chin.
Dogfish
See bowfin.
Burbot
Elongate freshwater cod of northern Europe and Asia and North America having barbels around its mouth
Dogfish
Any of various small sharks
Dogfish
Especially those from the family Squalidae
Dogfish
A catshark, any shark from family Scyliorhinidae
Dogfish
A kitefin shark, any shark from family Dalatiidae
Dogfish
(UK) Scyliorhinus canicula or Scyliorhinus stellaris
Dogfish
(Azores Is.) Scyliorhinus canicula
Dogfish
(Canada) Squalus suckleyi
Dogfish
(Bermuda) Mustelus canis
Dogfish
(Barbados) Bodianus rufus
Dogfish
(Guyana) Ginglymostoma cirratum or Mustelus canis
Dogfish
(Trinidad and Tobago) Ginglymostoma cirratum
Dogfish
(Namibia) Squalus acanthias, Squalus blainville, Squalus megalops, or Squalus mitsukurii
Dogfish
(US) The bowfin, Amia calva.
Dogfish
A small shark, of many species, of the genera Mustelus, Scyllium, Spinax, etc.
Dogfish
The bowfin (Amia calva). See Bowfin.
Dogfish
The burbot of Lake Erie.
Dogfish
Primitive long-bodies carnivorous freshwater fish with a very long dorsal fin; found in sluggish waters of North America
Dogfish
Any of several small sharks
Common Curiosities
What are the typical uses of burbot and dogfish?
Burbot is often used in sport fishing and for its healthy oils, while dogfish is targeted for its fins and meat in commercial fishing.
Can you eat both burbot and dogfish?
Yes, both are edible; burbot is mild and delicate, while dogfish has a stronger, tougher meat.
What are the peak fishing seasons for burbot and dogfish?
The peak season for fishing burbot is during the winter, especially under ice, due to their spawning behavior. In contrast, dogfish can be caught year-round, but commercial fishing often peaks when they migrate closer to shores.
How do burbot and dogfish reproduce?
Burbot spawn in winter under ice, while dogfish are ovoviviparous, bearing live young.
What is the primary diet of burbot and dogfish?
Burbot primarily feed on smaller fish and invertebrates in freshwater, whereas dogfish, being sharks, have a diet that includes fish, crustaceans, and squid in marine settings.
What type of water do burbot and dogfish live in?
Burbot live in freshwater, while dogfish are found in both freshwater and marine environments.
How can you identify a burbot from a dogfish?
Burbot have an elongated body with a chin barbel, while dogfish have spiny dorsal fins and no barbels.
Which fish is more popular for commercial fishing, burbot or dogfish?
Dogfish are more commonly targeted in commercial fishing, particularly for their fins and meat, while burbot is less commonly fished commercially but valued in recreational and subsistence fishing.
Are there conservation concerns for either burbot or dogfish?
Conservation concerns for dogfish, especially spiny dogfish, have been significant due to overfishing and demand for shark fins, whereas burbot have faced habitat loss and pollution issues, although they are generally not considered as threatened as dogfish.
How do the textures of burbot and dogfish compare when cooked?
Burbot meat is tender and flaky, similar to lobster when cooked, making it highly desirable for its texture. Dogfish, on the other hand, has a tougher, more rubbery texture, which can be challenging to prepare but holds up well in dishes like fish and chips or stews.
Share Your Discovery
Previous Comparison
Almost vs. Mostly
Next Comparison
Crow vs. VultureAuthor Spotlight
Written by
Maham Liaqat
Edited by
Tayyaba RehmanTayyaba Rehman is a distinguished writer, currently serving as a primary contributor to askdifference.com. As a researcher in semantics and etymology, Tayyaba's passion for the complexity of languages and their distinctions has found a perfect home on the platform. Tayyaba delves into the intricacies of language, distinguishing between commonly confused words and phrases, thereby providing clarity for readers worldwide.
